What We Gained…When We Gained It…and What Have We Lost?
We hear and see that voting rights are being weakened. But exactly what does that mean? We can still register. We can still vote. So what have we lost?
To answer that, we have to remember what earlier generations fought to gain. They needed more than a promise that they could vote. They needed protection when someone tried to stop them—and a fair chance for their votes to matter.
In 1870, we gained a constitutional promise.
The Fifteenth Amendment prohibited denying voting rights because of race, color, or previous enslavement.
But that promise did not stop threats, violence, and unfair rules from keeping Black Americans away from the ballot box for generations.
Some had to pay a poll tax before they could vote. Others faced so-called literacy tests, with officials deciding whose answers were acceptable.
Civil-rights accounts describe Black applicants being asked to guess how many jellybeans were in a jar. Imagine having your opportunity to register depend on satisfying the person asking that question.
Here in Louisiana, applicants had to give their exact age in years, months, and days. An error could mean rejection.
Knowing your birthday and being old enough to vote were not enough. You could be turned away for getting the calculation wrong.
Applicants could also be required to read and explain part of a constitution to an official’s satisfaction. Federal investigators documented people finding registration offices closed or being sent elsewhere when they tried to apply.
The person behind the counter had enormous power over the person standing in front of it.
Having a right on paper did not mean being able to use it.
Through much of that struggle, the Black church helped hold the community together.
Its meaning reached far beyond Sunday morning.
In a world that often treated Black people as less than equal, the church affirmed their worth. People could lead, teach, speak, organize, and care for one another.
Many churches became meeting places for the freedom struggle. People gathered to learn about their rights, prepare for voter registration, arrange transportation, and support neighbors facing hardship.
Faith helped sustain people who knew that standing up could cost them something. They prayed together, but they also planned together.
Not every church or pastor took the same position. Some feared the consequences of getting involved. But many Black churches provided space, leadership, resources, and relationships that helped make collective action possible.
The community had somewhere to gather—and gathering helped people discover what they could accomplish together.
In 1965, we gained stronger federal protection.
On August 6, President Lyndon Johnson signed the Voting Rights Act into law. It gave the federal government stronger tools to fight racial discrimination in voting.
One important safeguard required Louisiana and other covered places to get federal approval before changing voting rules or district maps. They had to show that the changes would not discriminate.
This was called preclearance. In plain language, someone was checking before a harmful change could take effect.
In 1982, we gained a stronger way to challenge unfair voting systems.
Congress strengthened Section 2 of the law. People could establish a violation by showing that a voting system produced discriminatory results. They did not have to prove that officials intended to discriminate.
That mattered. Showing how a system harms people can be very different from proving what its creators were thinking.
In Louisiana, the fight for congressional representation continued.
Black candidates ran before William Jefferson reached Congress. Their absence from office did not mean an absence of ambition, ability, or effort.
In 1983, a federal court found that Louisiana’s congressional map unlawfully weakened Black voting strength in the New Orleans area. Court-ordered changes made the 2nd District the state’s first majority-Black congressional district in the modern era.
In 1984, Judge Israel Augustine, a Black candidate, challenged incumbent Lindy Boggs, who was White. Boggs won, retaining substantial support among Black voters.
After Boggs announced her retirement, William Jefferson won the seat in 1990 and began serving in January 1991. He became Louisiana’s first Black member of Congress since Reconstruction.
The district mattered because it created a meaningful opportunity. The voters still made the choice.
Then came the reversals.
In 2013, we lost routine advance federal review.
In Shelby County v. Holder, the Supreme Court struck down the formula identifying which places needed federal approval before changing their voting practices.
Louisiana no longer had to get that automatic approval. Special court-ordered oversight remained possible, but the broad safeguard stopped working.
More of the burden fell on people bringing lawsuits to challenge changes, instead of having those changes checked beforehand.
In April 2026, challenging unfair district maps became harder.
In Louisiana v. Callais, the Supreme Court narrowed the protection against racial discrimination in districting.
For these challenges, the Court required evidence supporting a strong inference that officials intentionally drew districts to give minority voters less opportunity because of race.
That made an important part of the Voting Rights Act harder to use.
In May 2026, Louisiana removed its second majority-Black congressional district.
Louisiana had adopted a map with two majority-Black districts in 2024. Following the Supreme Court ruling, lawmakers moved to replace it with a map containing only one.
This was more than a change of lines on a map.
District lines determine which voters are grouped together to elect a representative. Those lines can keep a community together or divide it among several districts, weakening its influence.
Louisiana’s history shows why that matters. In her dissent in Callais, Justice Elena Kagan cited the lower court’s finding that Louisiana had never elected a Black member of Congress from a district without a Black majority.
The significance of this fight was visible at the State Capitol.
Only four men.
In the nearly 150 years since Reconstruction ended in 1877, only four Black men have represented Louisiana in the United States Congress:
William Jefferson. Cleo Fields. Cedric Richmond. Troy Carter.
And the first of those four did not begin serving until 1991.
On May 8, 2026, all four sat before a state Senate committee, asking lawmakers to preserve Louisiana’s second majority-Black congressional district.
Think about that. Every Black congressman Louisiana had sent to Washington since Reconstruction was seated at one table.
Pastor Theron J. Jackson of Shreveport, Gary Chambers of Baton Rouge, Bishop Paul S. Morton of New Orleans, and many others also addressed lawmakers. They brought the voices of churches, communities, and citizens into that room.
Those four congressmen were living evidence of how narrow the path to Congress had been for Black Louisianans. They had come together to ask lawmakers not to narrow it again.
Later that month, the lawmakers narrowed it again. Louisiana eliminated the second majority-Black district. The replacement map became law on May 29.
Black citizens in the redrawn district still had ballots. But their community’s ability to turn those ballots into representation had been diminished.
That is a loss of political power. It deserves to be stated plainly.
So what remains…and what have we lost?
The Fifteenth Amendment remains. The Voting Rights Act remains. Section 2 is permanent federal law. We have not lost our right to vote.
But we have lost routine federal review that once helped stop discriminatory changes before they took effect.
We have lost some of the legal strength used to challenge district maps that weaken Black voting power.
And Louisiana has lost one of its two majority-Black congressional districts.
The jellybean jar and the age calculation remind us why enforceable protections were necessary. Earlier generations knew that an official could acknowledge a right and still find a way to deny it.
They organized, gathered in churches, challenged unfair laws, and kept pressing for representation.
What they secured deserves more than a passing mention in a history lesson.
We need to know what we gained, when we gained it, and what it means when those hard-won protections are taken away.